The address on this listing and the phone number on this listing are not in the same building. That is the first thing a prom shopper in the south-metro Georgia suburbs needs to know about J. Andrew’s.
The wedding side — J. Andrew’s Bridal, which its own site and social accounts date to 2005 — answers at (770) 487-5680 and lists its address as 1100 Commerce Drive, Suite C, by appointment only. Its website is organized entirely around brides, bridesmaids, mothers, flower girls, alterations and gown preservation. Its Instagram bio puts the count at more than 500 gowns, with wedding dresses starting at $1,500; the site says designer gowns run up to $4,500.
The prom and special-occasion inventory sits at the Highway 74 North address on this listing, under a second name: Midnight by J. Andrew’s. Its Yelp listing describes it as a prom dress and special-occasion formalwear shop, gives a separate number, (678) 456-3530, and shows a Monday-through-Saturday retail schedule, closed Sunday, with Thursday running latest.
| What you’re shopping for | Name | Where | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prom, homecoming, special occasion | Midnight by J. Andrew’s | 277 Hwy 74 N | (678) 456-3530 |
| Wedding, bridesmaids, mothers | J. Andrew’s Bridal | 1100 Commerce Drive, Ste C | (770) 487-5680 |
Two brands are confirmed here through the designers’ own retailer locators: Alyce Paris and La Femme. Both run deep in long prom gowns and shorter special-occasion styles. Nothing else in the racks is verifiable from outside the store, so call before you commit to a drive for a specific label.
The Highway 74 stretch
277 Hwy 74 N is a 2006 retail building just north of the Highway 74 and Highway 54 intersection — the busiest crossroads in town. Commercial listings for the property name the surrounding retail: Mellow Mushroom, 3 Guys Golf Carts, The Avenue, West Park Place, Walmart, Home Depot. That mix is the practical case for the trip. Shoes, alteration drop-offs and a meal are all within the same few traffic lights, which matters when a dress hunt turns into three stops instead of one.
Peachtree City was laid out as a planned community in 1959 and built around roughly 100 miles of paved multi-use paths. The city runs a teen golf cart safety class specifically on the rules of that path system, and allows solo cart operation at 16, with or without a driver’s license. So a fair number of the juniors and seniors shopping for a dress here are getting around town on a cart, not a car — but Highway 74 is a state route with real traffic, and this is a trip most families make in the car.
Who shops here
Fayette County runs five public high schools: McIntosh, Starr’s Mill, Whitewater, Fayette County High and Sandy Creek. All five landed in the top 100 in Georgia on the 2026-2027 U.S. News rankings, with McIntosh at 14 and Starr’s Mill at 16 — a district where prom is a well-attended, well-photographed event across every zone. Our Lady of Mercy Catholic adds a private school in Fayetteville. Newnan and the rest of Coweta County are a short run west.
This is not a one-shop market. Fayetteville, the next town over, has a dedicated prom-and-pageant store on Highway 314, and Douglasville and Carrollton have their own formalwear shops on the west side of the metro. What J. Andrew’s offers instead is a business that has been fitting gowns in the same small city for two decades and split its prom stock into its own storefront rather than hanging it behind the wedding dresses.
One caution: the Commerce Drive and Highway 74 addresses both circulate on listing sites, sometimes attached to the same name. Confirm which door you want on the phone first.